2016 Hall of Fame

Those who have known me for years may remember that I have my own Hall of Fame method set up, which works something like this.

Each player gets a score that is a modeled on the MVP ballot. It is a weighted average of his career WARP3 – your best season in WARP counts 14 times (multiply WARP for that season by 14), then your second best season counts 9, third best 8, fourth best 7, and so on down to tenth – your tenth best, and all future seasons beyond tenth, count for 1. It achieves a sort of balance – decide for yourselves how properly weighted – between peak seasons and career length. The highest score in history belongs to Babe Ruth, with a 745. The lowest score that go someone into my Hall was 294 (Ned Garver, in 1968). We can safely say it takes a score of 300 just to make the conversation, and a 400 to have real shot. However, the score alone is no guarantee, because of the eligibility rules.

Starting from 1936, the year the actual Hall began, I begin adding players to the my Hall. The best players available, according to the MVP carer score, get the slots. I do limit my choices to players who have been retired for between 5 and 20 years (same as the real Hall). I allow one Hall of Fame opening per 12 real team-seasons in major league history – this was approximately the number of real Hall slots when I first developed the system about 10 years ago. There were some complicated rules regarding how to catch up from 1936-60, but that is all out of the way now. With 30 major league teams playing today, it means that my Hall is going to grow by 5 players every two years, alternating between 2 and 3 player classes.

2016, as it happens, is a three player class, and I do give a place to three players on the genuine ballot – Ken Griffey, Mike Mussina, and Trevor Hoffman.

Griffey is on the ballot for the first time, has a 458 MVP score, which ranks sixth among center fielders, and is the third-highest score on the ballot. He’s in easily.

Mike Mussina has a 434 MVP score and 100 career WARP3; his MVP score is 17th among starting pitchers. He was the first runner-up on my 2014 ballot, did that again in 2015, and makes it in 2016.

Trevor Hoffman has a 429 MVP score, which makes him the #3 Relief pitcher – behind Mariano Rivera and Joe Nathan, and just ahead of Goose Gossage.

My runners-up this year start with Sammy Sosa (425; he will get over the top in 2018), followed by Gary Sheffield (425, makes it in 2020), then Jim Edmonds (414), Jeff Kent (403), and Nomar Garciaparra (398). Edmonds is the first runner-up in 2020, and looks to have a good chance for 2021 induction.

The problem I would have in filling out a real ballot is that there are 11 players on it who are already in my own Hall, plus two more who will make it by 2020, plus another couple of possibilities beyond that.

In 2002, I put Alan Trammell (455) in on the first ballot. I did the same for Mark McGwire (432) in 2007, and for Tim Raines (457) in 2008, and for Edgar Martinez (461) in 2010, and for Jeff Bagwell (395) in 2011.

In 2013, with two slots available, I inducted Barry Bonds (744) and Roger Clemens (600) – the second and fifth highest MVP-career scores of all time.

And then in 2014 I put in Mike Piazza (446), plus the three from this year.

If you pressed me for who to drop, I’d pick between Bagwell (whose 395 is the lowest score) and Hoffman (I think my relief pitcher ratings are skewed for recent years, so I have less confidence in the values).

Scores for players on the ballot not already mentioned: Garret Anderson (207), Brad Ausmus (217), Luis Castillo (164), David Eckstein (184), Troy Glaus (352, which makes him #20 among 3B), Mark Grudzielanek (167), Mike Hampton (255), Jason Kendall (321), Mike Lowell (243), Fred McGriff (310), Curt Schilling (385 – was 3rd runner-up in 2013, and fifth runner-up in 2014), Lee Smith (339), Mike Sweeney (171), Billy Wagner (374), Larry Walker (311), and Randy Winn (254).

My full Hall list

johnswa01 WALTER JOHNSON 1936 SP 666.2
wagneho01 HONUS WAGNER 1936 SS 560.2
alexape01 PETE ALEXANDER 1936 SP 548.2
cobbty01 TY COBB 1936 CF 545.5
lajoina01 NAP LAJOIE 1936 SB 511.6
Runners-up 1936 mathech01 collied01 speaktr01 walshed01 barnero01

mathech01 CHRISTY MATHEWSON 1937 SP 505.7
collied01 EDDIE COLLINS 1937 SB 497.8
speaktr01 TRIS SPEAKER 1937 CF 488.4
walshed01 ED WALSH 1937 SP 479.2
barnero01 ROSS BARNES 1937 SB 474.5
Runners-up 1937 broutda01 connoro01 delahed01 ewingbu01 whitede01

broutda01 DAN BROUTHERS 1938 FB 471.1
connoro01 ROGER CONNOR 1938 FB 462.7
delahed01 ED DELAHANTY 1938 LF 462.5
ewingbu01 BUCK EWING 1938 C 442.7
whitede01 DEACON WHITE 1938 C 441.4
Runners-up 1938 youngcy01 ansonca01 kellyki01 flickel01 mcgrajo01

youngcy01 CY YOUNG 1939 SP 438.8
ansonca01 CAP ANSON 1939 FB 428.8
kellyki01 KING KELLY 1939 RF 418.8
flickel01 ELMER FLICK 1939 RF 404.6
mcgrajo01 JOHN MCGRAW 1939 TB 401.0
Runners-up 1939 glassja01 bennech01 hamilbi01 dahlebi01 jennihu01

glassja01 JACK GLASSCOCK 1940 SS 397.9
bennech01 CHARLIE BENNETT 1940 C 397.5
hamilbi01 BILLY HAMILTON 1940 CF 387.4
dahlebi01 BILL DAHLEN 1940 SS 386.8
jennihu01 HUGHIE JENNINGS 1940 SS 378.9
Runners-up 1940 jacksjo01 willine01 planked01 colliji01 dunlafr01

ruthba01 BABE RUTH 1941 RF 744.7
vanceda01 DAZZY VANCE 1941 SP 374.1
jacksjo01 JOE JACKSON 1941 RF 369.0
willine01 NED WILLIAMSON 1941 TB 368.7
Runners-up 1941 planked01 colliji01 dunlafr01 thompsa01 childcu01

planked01 EDDIE PLANK 1942 SP 365.8
colliji01 JIMMY COLLINS 1942 TB 347.5
dunlafr01 FRED DUNLAP 1942 SB 347.3
thompsa01 SAM THOMPSON 1942 RF 346.4
Runners-up 1942 childcu01 cicoted01 seweljo01 heilmha01 wadderu01

hornsro01 ROGERS HORNSBY 1943 SB 537.0
cochrmi01 MICKEY COCHRANE 1943 C 391.2
friscfr01 FRANKIE FRISCH 1943 SB 370.1
childcu01 CUPID CHILDS 1943 SB 344.7
Runners-up 1943 cicoted01 seweljo01 heilmha01 wadderu01 ruckena01

cicoted01 EDDIE CICOTTE 1944 SP 344.5
seweljo01 JOE SEWELL 1944 SS 344.1
heilmha01 HARRY HEILMANN 1944 RF 343.0
wadderu01 RUBE WADDELL 1944 SP 342.9
Runners-up 1944 ruckena01 davisge01 hinespa01 chancfr01 brownth01

gehrilo01 LOU GEHRIG 1945 FB 513.6
ruckena01 NAP RUCKER 1945 SP 339.6
davisge01 GEORGE DAVIS 1945 SS 337.4
hinespa01 PAUL HINES 1945 CF 337.4
Runners-up 1945 chancfr01 brownth01 richaha01 wallabo01 covelst01

chancfr01 FRANK CHANCE 1946 FB 336.9
brownth01 THREE_FINGER BROWN 1946 SP 332.1
richaha01 HARDY RICHARDSON 1946 SB 331.7
wallabo01 BOBBY WALLACE 1946 SS 330.8
Runners-up 1946 covelst01 keelewi01 tiernmi01 rusieam01 veachbo01

hartnga01 GABBY HARTNETT 1947 C 414.3
grovele01 LEFTY GROVE 1947 SP 385.1
ferrewe01 WES FERRELL 1947 SP 334.8
covelst01 STAN COVELESKI 1947 SP 329.8
Runners-up 1947 keelewi01 tiernmi01 rusieam01 veachbo01 longhe01

gehrich01 CHARLIE GEHRINGER 1948 SB 410.9
keelewi01 WILLIE KEELER 1948 RF 329.1
tiernmi01 MIKE TIERNAN 1948 RF 327.9
rusieam01 AMOS RUSIE 1948 SP 327.7
Runners-up 1948 veachbo01 longhe01 sislege01 clarkjo01 bancrda01

hubbeca01 CARL HUBBELL 1949 SP 422.6
veachbo01 BOBBY VEACH 1949 LF 324.0
longhe01 HERMAN LONG 1949 SS 323.7
sislege01 GEORGE SISLER 1949 FB 321.6
Runners-up 1949 clarkjo01 bancrda01 terrybi01 sheckji01 whitnji01

simmoal01 AL SIMMONS 1950 LF 347.8
clarkjo01 JOHN CLARKSON 1950 SP 321.4
bancrda01 DAVE BANCROFT 1950 SS 317.1
terrybi01 BILL TERRY 1950 FB 315.7
Runners-up 1950 sheckji01 whitnji01 burkeje01 grohhe01 wheatza01

foxxji01 JIMMIE FOXX 1951 FB 438.0
cronijo01 JOE CRONIN 1951 SS 418.7
wanerpa01 PAUL WANER 1951 RF 417.4
johnsbo01 BOB JOHNSON 1951 LF 320.0
Runners-up 1951 warnelo01 camildo01 sheckji01 whitnji01 burkeje01

dickebi01 BILL DICKEY 1952 C 442.7
lyonste01 TED LYONS 1952 SP 320.2
warnelo01 LON WARNEKE 1952 SP 319.0
bartedi01 DICK BARTELL 1952 SS 318.7
Runners-up 1952 camildo01 sheckji01 whitnji01 burkeje01 grohhe01

ottme01 MEL OTT 1953 RF 513.8
hermabi01 BILLY HERMAN 1953 SB 374.1
greenha01 HANK GREENBERG 1953 FB 353.5
deandi01 DIZZY DEAN 1953 SP 345.3
Runners-up 1953 passecl01 hackst01 camildo01 sheckji01 whitnji01

vaughar01 ARKY VAUGHAN 1954 SS 446.9
medwijo01 JOE MEDWICK 1954 LF 392.0
passecl01 CLAUDE PASSEAU 1954 SP 330.9
hackst01 STAN HACK 1954 TB 319.4
Runners-up 1954 camildo01 sheckji01 whitnji01 burkeje01 grohhe01

camildo01 DOLPH CAMILLI 1955 FB 317.3
sheckji01 JIMMY SHECKARD 1955 LF 315.1
whitnji01 JIM WHITNEY 1955 SP 313.3
burkeje01 JESSE BURKETT 1955 LF 313.2
Runners-up 1955 grohhe01 cliftha01 wheatza01 galanau01 orourji01

gordojo01 JOE GORDON 1956 SB 380.0
applilu01 LUKE APPLING 1956 SS 372.1
waltebu01 BUCKY WALTERS 1956 SP 356.3
Runners-up 1956 grohhe01 cliftha01 wheatza01 galanau01 orourji01

dimagjo01 JOE DIMAGGIO 1957 CF 474.5
doerrbo01 BOBBY DOERR 1957 SB 382.3
grohhe01 HEINIE GROH 1957 TB 312.1
Runners-up 1957 cliftha01 wheatza01 galanau01 orourji01 clarkfr01

boudrlo01 LOU BOUDREAU 1958 SS 413.9
cliftha01 HARLOND CLIFT 1958 TB 311.9
wheatza01 ZACK WHEAT 1958 LF 310.4
Runners-up 1958 galanau01 orourji01 clarkfr01 faberre01 gosligo01

mizejo01 JOHNNY MIZE 1959 FB 407.3
leonadu02 DUTCH LEONARD 1959 SP 325.0
nichobi01 BILL NICHOLSON 1959 RF 324.5
Runners-up 1959 galanau01 orourji01 clarkfr01 faberre01 gosligo01

galanau01 AUGIE GALAN 1960 LF 310.1
orourji01 JIM O’ROURKE 1960 LF 309.4
clarkfr01 FRED CLARKE 1960 LF 309.3
Runners-up 1960 faberre01 gosligo01 ruffire01 jackstr01 seymocy01

newhoha01 HAL NEWHOUSER 1961 SP 423.7
kinerra01 RALPH KINER 1961 LF 354.0
stephve01 VERN STEPHENS 1961 SS 313.4
Runners-up 1961 ruffire01 kellech01 elliobo01 kleinch01 stanked01

fellebo01 BOB FELLER 1962 SP 448.2
robinja02 JACKIE ROBINSON 1962 SB 419.9
ruffire01 RED RUFFING 1962 SP 307.8
Runners-up 1962 kellech01 elliobo01 kleinch01 stanked01 rosenal01

camparo01 ROY CAMPANELLA 1963 C 379.5
troutdi01 DIZZY TROUT 1963 SP 335.5
kellech01 CHARLIE KELLER 1963 LF 306.8
Runners-up 1963 elliobo01 kleinch01 stanked01 rosenal01 peskyjo01

reesepe01 PEE_WEE REESE 1964 SS 327.9
Runners-up 1964 lemonbo01 elliobo01 kleinch01 stanked01 rosenal01

lemonbo01 BOB LEMON 1965 SP 307.7
elliobo01 BOB ELLIOTT 1965 TB 304.8
Runners-up 1965 kleinch01 stanked01 slaugen01 rosenal01 peskyjo01

willite01 TED WILLIAMS 1966 LF 587.6
stanked01 EDDIE STANKY 1966 SB 301.4
Runners-up 1966 slaugen01 rosenal01 peskyjo01 freylo01 brechha01

slaugen01 ENOS SLAUGHTER 1967 RF 295.7
Runners-up 1967 garvene01 rosenal01 peskyjo01 freylo01 brechha01

ashburi01 RICHIE ASHBURN 1968 CF 438.4
garvene01 NED GARVER 1968 SP 293.5
Runners-up 1968 rosenal01 peskyjo01 freylo01 brechha01 sainjo01

musiast01 STAN MUSIAL 1969 LF 572.0
wynnea01 EARLY WYNN 1969 SP 313.8
Runners-up 1969 hodgegi01 schoere01 rosenal01 peskyjo01 freylo01

snidedu01 DUKE SNIDER 1970 CF 318.1
piercbi02 BILLY PIERCE 1970 SP 308.9
Runners-up 1970 hodgegi01 schoere01 rosenal01 peskyjo01 brechha01

spahnwa01 WARREN SPAHN 1971 SP 470.2
berrayo01 YOGI BERRA 1971 C 397.8
Runners-up 1971 hodgegi01 foxne01 schoere01 rosenal01 peskyjo01

roberro01 ROBIN ROBERTS 1972 SP 420.5
koufasa01 SANDY KOUFAX 1972 SP 404.5
Runners-up 1972 frienbo01 hodgegi01 foxne01 schoere01 rosenal01

frienbo01 BOB FRIEND 1973 SP 307.9
hodgegi01 GIL HODGES 1973 FB 304.1
Runners-up 1973 foxne01 schoere01 rosenal01 peskyjo01 fordwh01

mantlmi01 MICKEY MANTLE 1974 CF 490.9
matheed01 EDDIE MATHEWS 1974 TB 457.0
Runners-up 1974 foxne01 schoere01 rosenal01 peskyjo01 fordwh01

drysddo01 DON DRYSDALE 1975 SP 383.1
boyerke01 KEN BOYER 1975 TB 370.8
Runners-up 1975 foxne01 schoere01 rosenal01 peskyjo01 fordwh01

foxne01 NELLIE FOX 1976 SB 300.7
schoere01 RED SCHOENDIENST 1976 SB 299.6
Runners-up 1976 rosenal01 fordwh01 colavro01 sainjo01 jacksla01

bankser01 ERNIE BANKS 1977 SS 414.6
bunniji01 JIM BUNNING 1977 SP 370.7
Runners-up 1977 pascuca02 rosenal01 fordwh01 colavro01 jacksla01

clemero01 ROBERTO CLEMENTE 1978 RF 363.2
wilheho01 HOYT WILHELM 1978 RP 310.5
Runners-up 1978 pascuca02 mazerbi01 fordwh01 colavro01 jacksla01

mayswi01 WILLIE MAYS 1979 CF 637.8
pascuca02 CAMILO PASCUAL 1979 SP 310.3
mazerbi01 BILL MAZEROSKI 1979 SB 298.5
Runners-up 1979 fordwh01 callijo01 colavro01 jacksla01 antonjo02

santoro01 RON SANTO 1980 TB 459.8
kalinal01 AL KALINE 1980 RF 377.8
Runners-up 1980 cepedor01 cashno01 fordwh01 callijo01 colavro01

gibsobo01 BOB GIBSON 1981 SP 467.3
maricju01 JUAN MARICHAL 1981 SP 389.8
Runners-up 1981 cepedor01 cashno01 killeha01 fordwh01 callijo01

aaronha01 HANK AARON 1982 RF 550.0
robinfr02 FRANK ROBINSON 1982 RF 477.7
Runners-up 1982 willibi01 cepedor01 freehbi01 cashno01 killeha01

wynnji01 JIM WYNN 1983 CF 421.5
allendi01 DICK ALLEN 1983 TB 410.7
Runners-up 1983 torrejo01 robinbr01 willibi01 cepedor01 freehbi01

torrejo01 JOE TORRE 1984 C 358.0
woodwi01 WILBUR WOOD 1984 SP 345.5
Runners-up 1984 robinbr01 willibi01 cepedor01 freehbi01 cashno01

munsoth01 THURMAN MUNSON 1985 C 350.7
robinbr01 BROOKS ROBINSON 1985 TB 344.9
willibi01 BILLY WILLIAMS 1985 LF 325.9
Runners-up 1985 cepedor01 whitero01 freehbi01 cashno01 hunteca01

mccovwi01 WILLIE MCCOVEY 1986 FB 373.7
cepedor01 ORLANDO CEPEDA 1986 FB 325.3
Runners-up 1986 whitero01 freehbi01 cashno01 hunteca01 hillejo01

bondsbo01 BOBBY BONDS 1987 RF 344.9
whitero01 ROY WHITE 1987 LF 319.4
Runners-up 1987 marshmi01 freehbi01 cashno01 hunteca01 hillejo01

tiantlu01 LUIS TIANT 1988 SP 345.9
stargwi01 WILLIE STARGELL 1988 LF 325.3
Runners-up 1988 smithre06 marshmi01 freehbi01 cashno01 hunteca01

benchjo01 JOHNNY BENCH 1989 C 505.3
yastrca01 CARL YASTRZEMSKI 1989 LF 416.6
Runners-up 1989 perryga01 jenkife01 tenacge01 campabe01 smithre06

morgajo02 JOE MORGAN 1990 SB 508.5
perryga01 GAYLORD PERRY 1990 SP 415.3
Runners-up 1990 palmeji01 jenkife01 tenacge01 campabe01 smithre06

carewro01 ROD CAREW 1991 SB 409.1
palmeji01 JIM PALMER 1991 SP 390.1
jenkife01 FERGIE JENKINS 1991 SP 382.9
Runners-up 1991 fingero01 tenacge01 campabe01 smithre06 marshmi01

grichbo01 BOBBY GRICH 1992 SB 473.2
seaveto01 TOM SEAVER 1992 SP 468.6
Runners-up 1992 rosepe01 fingero01 tenacge01 campabe01 fostege01

rosepe01 PETE ROSE 1993 LF 405.5
jacksre01 REGGIE JACKSON 1993 RF 395.6
Runners-up 1993 niekrph01 fingero01 tenacge01 campabe01 fostege01

carltst01 STEVE CARLTON 1994 SP 462.1
niekrph01 PHIL NIEKRO 1994 SP 375.3
Runners-up 1994 fingero01 tenacge01 conceda01 nettlgr01 cruzjo01

schmimi01 MIKE SCHMIDT 1995 TB 552.5
fingero01 ROLLIE FINGERS 1995 RP 368.9
evansda01 DARRELL EVANS 1995 TB 367.3
Runners-up 1995 tenacge01 conceda01 nettlgr01 cruzjo01 bellbu01

hernake01 KEITH HERNANDEZ 1996 FB 383.9
tenacge01 GENE TENACE 1996 C 367.2
Runners-up 1996 conceda01 nettlgr01 cruzjo01 lemonch01 bellbu01

evansdw01 DWIGHT EVANS 1997 RF 418.2
conceda01 DAVE CONCEPCION 1997 SS 359.5
Runners-up 1997 nettlgr01 cruzjo01 lemonch01 bellbu01 campabe01

cartega01 GARY CARTER 1998 C 474.6
blylebe01 BERT BLYLEVEN 1998 SP 422.2
nettlgr01 GRAIG NETTLES 1998 TB 358.1
Runners-up 1998 guerrpe01 cruzjo01 randowi01 lemonch01 bellbu01

brettge01 GEORGE BRETT 1999 TB 480.9
yountro01 ROBIN YOUNT 1999 SS 429.6
Runners-up 1999 ryanno01 fiskca01 tananfr01 guerrpe01 cruzjo01

ryanno01 NOLAN RYAN 2000 SP 403.9
fiskca01 CARLTON FISK 2000 C 403.7
gossari01 RICH GOSSAGE 2000 RP 389.5
Runners-up 2000 tananfr01 guerrpe01 cruzjo01 randowi01 lemonch01

whitalo01 LOU WHITAKER 2001 SB 373.6
mattido01 DON MATTINGLY 2001 FB 368.5
Runners-up 2001 tananfr01 puckeki01 guerrpe01 cruzjo01 randowi01

trammal01 ALAN TRAMMELL 2002 SS 454.8
smithoz01 OZZIE SMITH 2002 SS 415.2
dawsoan01 ANDRE DAWSON 2002 CF 383.1
Runners-up 2002 violafr01 tananfr01 puckeki01 guerrpe01 cruzjo01

sandbry01 RYNE SANDBERG 2003 SB 428.7
violafr01 FRANK VIOLA 2003 SP 373.1
Runners-up 2003 murraed02 tananfr01 puckeki01 guerrpe01 cruzjo01

molitpa01 PAUL MOLITOR 2004 TB 422.5
eckerde01 DENNIS ECKERSLEY 2004 SP 396.2
murraed02 EDDIE MURRAY 2004 FB 370.2
Runners-up 2004 tananfr01 puckeki01 guerrpe01 cruzjo01 randowi01

boggswa01 WADE BOGGS 2005 TB 493.2
phillto02 TONY PHILLIPS 2005 LF 392.4
Runners-up 2005 tananfr01 puckeki01 guerrpe01 cruzjo01 randowi01

belleal01 ALBERT BELLE 2006 LF 455.0
hershor01 OREL HERSHISER 2006 SP 383.2
clarkwi02 WILL CLARK 2006 FB 372.5
Runners-up 2006 tananfr01 goodedw01 puckeki01 jonesdo01 guerrpe01

ripkeca01 CAL RIPKEN 2007 SS 559.0
mcgwima01 MARK MCGWIRE 2007 FB 432.2
Runners-up 2007 saberbr01 gwynnto01 fernato01 tananfr01 goodedw01

raineti01 TIM RAINES 2008 LF 457.3
saberbr01 BRET SABERHAGEN 2008 SP 403.6
gwynnto01 TONY GWYNN 2008 RF 389.9
Runners-up 2008 finlech01 fernato01 tananfr01 goodedw01 puckeki01

henderi01 RICKEY HENDERSON 2009 LF 594.3
finlech01 CHUCK FINLEY 2009 SP 379.3
Runners-up 2009 coneda01 fernato01 tananfr01 goodedw01 puckeki01

martied01 EDGAR MARTINEZ 2010 OT 460.6
alomaro01 ROBERTO ALOMAR 2010 SB 437.6
larkiba01 BARRY LARKIN 2010 SS 435.8
Runners-up 2010 venturo01 coneda01 fernato01 appieke01 tananfr01

brownke01 KEVIN BROWN 2011 SP 409.9
bagweje01 JEFF BAGWELL 2011 FB 395.2
Runners-up 2011 venturo01 olerujo01 coneda01 fernato01 appieke01

willibe02 BERNIE WILLIAMS 2012 CF 406.4
venturo01 ROBIN VENTURA 2012 TB 382.1
olerujo01 JOHN OLERUD 2012 FB 379.6
Runners-up 2012 coneda01 fernato01 appieke01 tananfr01 palmera01

bondsba01 BARRY BONDS 2013 LF 744.2
clemero02 ROGER CLEMENS 2013 SP 600.2
Runners-up 2013 piazzmi01 sosasa01 schilcu01 coneda01 fernato01

maddugr01 GREG MADDUX 2014 SP 534.2
thomafr04 FRANK THOMAS 2014 FB 470.2
piazzmi01 MIKE PIAZZA 2014 C 445.7
Runners-up 2014 mussimi01 sosasa01 kentje01 gonzalu01 schilcu01

johnsra05 RANDY JOHNSON 2015 SP 494.9
martipe02 PEDRO MARTINEZ 2015 SP 483.5
Runners-up 2015 mussimi01 sosasa01 sheffga01 kentje01 garcino01

griffke02 KEN GRIFFEY 2016 CF 457.7
mussimi01 MIKE MUSSINA 2016 SP 433.9
hoffmtr01 TREVOR HOFFMAN 2016 RP 428.6
Runners-up 2016 sosasa01 sheffga01 edmonji01 kentje01 garcino01

rodriiv01 IVAN RODRIGUEZ 2017 C 483.7
ramirma02 MANNY RAMIREZ 2017 LF 433.2
Runners-up 2017 posadjo01 sosasa01 sheffga01 edmonji01 kentje01

rolensc01 SCOTT ROLEN 2018 TB 428.6
posadjo01 JORGE POSADA 2018 C 428.5
sosasa01 SAMMY SOSA 2018 RF 425.3
Runners-up 2018 sheffga01 santajo01 edmonji01 jonesch06 kentje01

riverma01 MARIANO RIVERA 2019 RP 594.9
hallaro01 ROY HALLADAY 2019 SP 451.8
Runners-up 2019 sheffga01 santajo01 edmonji01 heltoto01 jonesch06

giambja01 JASON GIAMBI 2020 FB 443.8
sheffga01 GARY SHEFFIELD 2020 RF 424.6
santajo01 JOHAN SANTANA 2020 SP 415.1
Runners-up 2020 edmonji01 heltoto01 jonesch06 kentje01 thomeji01